EDIT: I figured out what was wrong. I was looking at my voting timesheet and I think its the 12 hour limit thing that prevented me from getting the rewards for some of my votes (greyed out ones). The first grey was kinda obvious since I voted exactly 12 hours apart so I didn't pay it much mind and the second day I ended up voting 40 minutes past the 12 hour limit to be sure it registered without realizing it would affect the schedule of my morning votes. I thought the 12 hour limit was only applied to the first time using the phone data and then I could just use the counters from the actual site (the 24 hour ones respectively), but by doing that I ended up submitting my morning votes before the 12 hours hence why no rewards. It just so happened that it coincided with the times the servers got reset. Sorry for posting so much but I figured I should update to save the GMs from double checking and in case anyone ever ran into a similar problem.